Numbers: Efficiency and Productivity in Relation to Payment Plans

April 1, 2025
How you pay your technicians can have a direct effect on their productivity and efficiency.
Team Structure Trends, Technician pay and efficiency and productivity
The Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey found a clear correlation between technician pay structure and efficiency/productivity. Hourly pay is the most common approach (27%), followed by hourly plus commission (22%). Only 3% of technicians receive a salary plus commission.
 
The data shows that 43% of flat-rate and salaried technicians achieve efficiency rates over 100%, compared to a significant decrease for hourly and hourly-plus-commission structures. However, the highest productivity over 100% is seen in flat-rate and salary-plus-commission technicians, at 29% each.
 
The survey results suggest that the type of technician pay structure impacts their efficiency and productivity levels. Flat-rate and salary-plus-commission arrangements appear to yield the best results in this regard.
 
Technician pay structures, efficiency and productivity
 
Hourly: 27%
Technician efficiency over 100% - 12%
Technician productivity over 100% - 7%
 
Hourly + commission: 22% 
Technician productivity over 100% - 15%
Technician efficiency over 100% - 18%
 
Flat rate: 22% 
Technician efficiency over 100% - 43%
Technician productivity over 100% - 29%
 
Salary: 11%
Technician efficiency over 100% - 43%
Technician productivity over 100% - 12%
 
Salary plus commission: 3%
Technician efficiency over 100% - 14%
Technician productivity over 100% - 29%
 
Other: 15%
Some of the other forms of remuneration that were reported in the Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey were: flat rate plus guarantee, flat rate plus bonuses, multilevel flat rate and hourly plus bonus, and flagged hours.

 

Sponsored Recommendations

Free Resources for Shops Like Yours

View insights, research and solutions curated specifically for shops like yours.

Deliver a First-Class Guest Experience

Our dedicated Valvoline Trusted Advisor Sales and Support Team provides hands-on classroom and targeted in-store coaching to help your employees become more skilled at selling...

Promote Growth on Two Fronts: Existing and New Customers

Increase Sales and Customer Traffic To Your Store(s).

Differentiate Your Services and Increase Revenue

Reinvigorate your team and business success behind Valvoline's proven strategy that helps separate your business from competitors and create meaningful growth in sales and customer...